Jesse Metcalfe Tom Endler Robin Givens Principal Kinney Melissa Joan Hart Grace Wesley Brad Heller School Attorney Ernie Hudson Judge Stennis Hayley Orrantia Brooke Thawley Pat Boone Walter Wesley Paul Kwo Martin Yip Trisha LaFache Amy Ryan Jon Lindstrom Superintendent Jim Powell Maria Canals-Barrera Catherine Thawley Benjamin Ochieng Reverend Jude Sadie Robertson Marlene Fred Thompson Senior Pastor David A.R. White Pastor Dave Hill Ray Wise Peter Kane Tommy Blaze Waiter Natalie Canerday Mrs. Rizzo Verda Davenport First Teacher Abigail Duhon Jessica Jesse Wang Martin's Father